Homonyms and the subjugation of your husband

Why is it that straight people can't say faggot, white people can't say nigger, and Japanese people can't say their R's?

I attempted to solve the latter part of the puzzle last night, but it remains a quandary to which I can offer no answer, even after 2 hours of practicing "Lice" and "Rice", "Wrong" and "Long" and "Lung" and "Rung" with Hiro. Long, Wrong, Long, Wrong, Long, Wrong. I haven't a clue what you are saying, Hiro.

"Put your tongue up against your teeth, your upper teeth. Now say, luh, luh, long!"

"Ruh, ruh wrong."

"No, luh, luh long!"

"Ruh, ruh, wrong."

We practice every variation of tongue arrangement imaginable, but were unable to produce any consistent results that could help Hiro with the R and the L, the most challenging facet of the English language. Hiro pulled his face and stretched his cheeks, he clicked his tongue and rolled his R's deep in his throat, but after putting a short sentence together the sound came out, well, wrong. Impossible.

Hiro gave up for the evening, but decided to challenge me with some similar linguistic difficulties contained in the Japanese language.

"Hashi" is both chopsticks and bridge. "Ame" is candy and rain. "Su" is vinegar, but also a bird's nest. Only slight variations exist in the pronunciation of the words, but, as with any language, poor enunciation can be compensated through proper context.

The most interesting pseudo-homonym in Japanese, though, is the strange pairing of prisoner and husband, both pronounced so similarly that it can't be a coincidence; nothing in Japan is a coincidence.

Every kanji has a meaning, and every word is made of multiple kanji, revealing the ancient origins or the word--for example: keitai, or cellphone, is a combination of the character for "to carry with" and "sword slung on the hip." It's practical. It makes sense.

So what can we learn from the similarity of prisoner and husband? Hiro couldn't explain it to me, but I'm certain the correlation isn't simply superficial.

Posted by brett at 03:08 PM Tokyo time

Comments

As a student of Anthropology...ahem. Ha, sorry, thought it would be funny to begin in that way. But no, seriously, our vocal chords are shaped early on in our existance by the sounds we make. That is why some people will NEVER lose their accents. That is why Ricky Ricardo maintained the thick Cubano sound after all of those years and that is why Hiro can't say his r's. I had a Japanese Archaeology teacher explain this to me. I know you from Flickr...by the way.

Posted by Vanessa on September 26, 2004 05:22 AM Tokyo time
Skeet
front page

Archived Skeet
April 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
November 2004
October 2004
September 2004
August 2004
July 2004
June 2004

Recent Skeet
Moved
Dead on
I'm a hater
Neat
Soccer season
Ugh
We Got It 4 Cheap
Depressing
Monday, Monday, Monday
Friday the 13th